Comments on: Debate Notes

By: Bitterb4

Bitterb4 — Fri, 17 Oct 2008 03:59:57 +0000

Still worried about the Bradley Effect, but starting to ponder the real possibility of an Obama administration after last night’s debate. McCain has improved though…he didn’t call himself a “maverick” once (i think) His campaign has felt like a barroom brawl and that he would win just by being the last person standing. Problem is if you take everybody out who is going to help you govern. Lewis should be repudiated…fire Cox.. I don’t need any lectures, 527 attack ads during Special House elections trying to remind voters of Rev Wright flap.. references to Michelle Obama’s comment “for the first time i’m proud of my country.” McCain is out of touch in the sense that the pendulum has swung the other way on the Reagan era mandates. I don’t know if Obama’s plans will work, but its time for a change. McCain has never given me the impression that he can bring people together, but he throws some pretty wild haymakers!

By: Timothy Burke

Timothy Burke — Fri, 17 Oct 2008 01:50:35 +0000

It’s mostly about being a jerk, yeah–but it seems to me that a newly minted Ph.D who is a jerk in the same way comes off slightly differently than a long-serving Ph.D who has been doing this kind of schtick for years and years.

By: hestal

hestal — Thu, 16 Oct 2008 19:36:47 +0000

Are the negative characteristics you describe applicable only to “old” professors?

If it is, are there very many of them? Are they commonplace in academia? If they are, then why?

Perhaps a certain percentage of old men are like McCain no matter their profession. But still, if that is true, then why?

If “old” is the key, then I suppose there is nothing more to say, except, “watch out.”

By: Timothy Burke

Timothy Burke — Thu, 16 Oct 2008 19:19:42 +0000

Substantively, he made some good points about his own record and even about some of Obama’s policy positions, but they were either accented very strangely by his emotional demeanor, which seemed all out of proportion to the discussion, or they drowned every time he felt obligated to go on a string-of-consciousness run of nasty talking points. There were some Jekyll and Hyde moments.

By: David Chudzicki

David Chudzicki — Thu, 16 Oct 2008 18:43:31 +0000

On (2), I thought he mostly looked sad. I guess it’s the thing where he shows us he empathizes with all the hurt and fear we feel about whatever. But seriously, he looked like he was about to cry over the economy. This is “not presidential.”

But I want to give him some credit for reiterating the ethanol position. (Extra credit if he loses Indiana.)